An editorial


National Healthcare Is National Defense.

According to the Wall Street Journal, South Korea is capable of testing 20,000 people a day for coronavirus. Way more than the US. How much more? That’s a difficult question–because the number being tested in the US is uncertain. We can say with confidence, however, that the US is testing fewer than 20,000 people a day.

For the scale of this US failure, consider the numbers.

The population of South Korea is 51,000,000. The population of the US 300,000,000. If the US were up to speed the way South Korea is, it would be capable of testing around 115,000 people a day. Our World in Data reports that as of March 20, South Korea had tested 317,000 people for CV. In the US, the CDC estimated that 37,500 people had been tested by that date.

A pandemic is a world war. Nations in the world face a common enemy. Some nations are deploying more powerful weapons on the battlefront than others. How is it that South Korea is so much more effective facing this foe than the US?

One inescapable conclusion is that a country with a fully developed and functioning national health system has superior procedures and weapons to deploy. South Korea has those things; the US does not.

Can we afford NOT to have a fully developed and functioning national health system? It is unlikely that this is the last world war of this kind we will fight.

Citizens vote for leaders that “keep us safe.” The US invests hundreds of billions in systems dedicated to that task. The US takes pride in its military preparedness. It can develop weapons systems, gather intelligence, deploy force by land, sea, air, and cyber. The US military keeps its thumb on the world pulse 24 hours a day. Much of the time, however, war material and personnel are just sitting there, bombs not going off, boots not on the ground. They’re training. They’re ready. We’re safe, the argument goes, because they are ready.

The US needs to begin thinking of a national health system as a form of national defense, as an investment on par with national defense. The Defense Department budget in 2019 was $686 billion. The CDC budget in 2019 was $11 billion, Health and Human Services $70 billion.

The US has the best healthcare system in the world. It is common to hear that assertion. The system is excellent, for some people. However, we are now seeing its widespread failure, the gaps in the system that may result in the deaths of hundreds of thousands, possibly millions of people. We would not be satisfied with a national defense system that was excellent only for part of the population. National defense protects everyone. The investment in military preparedness is done for senators and CEO’s, for truck drivers and restaurant workers, for children and senior citizens; even for the homeless and for illegal immigrants.

Dubai is testing 13,000 people a day for coronavirus. The US is still scrambling to initiate widespread testing, to produce masks and ventilators. Military hospital ships, it was announced weeks ago, are being deployed; one may arrive in New York harbor by the end of this month.

It might arrive. Maybe by the end of this month.

The metaphor is instructive. How long does it take for an ocean going vessel to change course? They do not speed to their destination. In the US military there are Rapid Deployment Forces. In the US health system, rapid response is out of the question. And people are going to die.

We should demand better.

1 Comment

  1. katcunning says:

    Excellent editorial, Rick! I shared it on Facebook. You should submit a letter to the editors of the NYT/WaPo, etc.

Leave a Reply